The Generosity Game


DR SHAADY HARRISON | 4 minutes

It’s 2010, and AI is still a bit of a nerdy fantasy. It’s the stuff of science fiction, and getting a venture capitalist to take it seriously is about as likely as getting blood out of a stone.

Until along comes former child chess prodigy Demis Hassabis.

At thirty-four years old, the DeepMind CEO has a beautifully simple mission – solve intelligence, then use that to solve everything else. Over the next decade, the AI start-up (by now owned by Google) gets to work on one of biology’s oldest and most complicated problems: how do the thousands of tiny proteins that decide everything in our body fold into perfect 3D shapes?

Up until now, cracking a single one could easily swallow an entire PhD and six-figure budget.

And then in 2020 his team in King’s Cross unveils an AI model that can do it in minutes.

They’re about to make some serious money; billions of pounds’ worth of drugs are sitting on the other side of this problem – every pharmaceutical company on the planet gets ready to line up with its chequebook and a very large pen.

So DeepMind do what any self-respecting tech giant would, and give the entire database to the world for free.

Factory Settings

Doctors measure lots of developmental milestones. There are the obvious things like rolling over and sitting up straight, and then there are the less photogenic ones that tend to slip by unnoticed.

Somewhere around the second year of life, a toddler barely steady on their feet will start to abandon whatever they’re doing to help a complete stranger pick something up they’ve dropped. This behaviour happens irrespective of whether there’s praise, an audience or the offer of a biscuit.

The urge to help others is written into the instruction manual of being a human.

Giving stuff to other people lights up the ventral striatum, the same reward circuitry that activates when money lands in our own pocket. This makes sense – we evolved in groups where taking care of each other was deeply valuable; hoarding a load of berries might have won the odd afternoon, but it was a terrible long-term strategy in the face of a cold and miserable winter.

Evolution spent millions of years making generosity feel good, which raises an awkward question.

Why don’t we do more of it?

 

Bad Maths

As adults, whenever we’re deciding whether to do something generous the brain runs a quick and dirty calculation of cost against benefit.

Unfortunately, it almost always gets the answer wrong.

When trying to figure out the value of a kind gesture, we simulate other people’s inner lives by using our own. With no direct line into other humans’ minds, we borrow our own version of reality as a template and adjust from there; from where we’re standing a quick message, couple of encouraging words or an introduction involves no real cost, so we assume it’ll mean roughly the same to the person on the receiving end.

The brain on the other side sees a very different picture.

For a species that survived by sticking together, being thought about is one of the oldest safety signals in the book. Kindness has a remarkably long psychological shelf life, which goes a long way in explaining why most of us can still name the people who went out of their way to help us a decade ago.

Return To Sender

Psychologists have run the experiment time and time again – humans dramatically underestimate the impact of their generosity on other people.

But more ironically, we dramatically underestimate the impact on ourselves.

Doing something nice for another human can boost mood, increase a sense of purpose, strengthen relationships and make us feel more connected in a world that’s increasingly obsessed with keeping score. It can also dampen the body’s stress response, shifting us further away from survival mode into a calmer, more expansive way of thinking.

Autonomy matters here – there’s a difference between genuinely wanting to do something and feeling like we should; forced generosity is about as restorative as forced fun.

Given freely, small gestures travel both ways. One person gets proof they were thought about; the other gets proof they had something to spare.

Enjoy this article?

Don’t miss the next one.

Absolutely no spam. Ever.

About The Author

Shaady Harrison is a British medical doctor, writer and executive advisor specialising in neuroscience, leadership and high performance.

READ NEXT